We found 764 producing agents in Monroe County, NY
We analyze local sales records and verified reviews across Monroe County, NY to match you with the top real estate agents in the county. Free for buyers and sellers.
Top real estate agents in Monroe County, NY
Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

Colleen BurkePreferred
Colleen Burke Realty
★★★★★100+ sales
Hi! My name is Colleen Burke and I am an experienced real estate broker, property manager, and real estate investor with over 14 years of combined experience in the greater Rochester, New York area. I have done work as a real estate agent for new home sales at Stone Hill Estates in Pittsford, NY and was also the property manager for Corn Hill Landing and the Warner Building. Not only am I a real estate broker and experienced property manager, I also own my own investment property as well! Whether buying your dream home or your next investment property I would be honored to represent you!

Anthony Butera
Keller Williams Realty
★★★★★2,600+ sales
As a lifelong resident of Rochester, NY and Broker @ Keller Williams Realty I use my experience and knowledge to locate your future home in your desired neighborhood of choice. I listen and observe your wants and needs and I will work tirelessly on your behalf. My construction background provides important knowledge with existing or new built construction for my clients.Whether you're a first time home buyer, relocating, investing or building your dream home, based on your needs, I guide you through the home buying or selling process. I will provide professional advice on current market trends, negotiate contract terms, monitor all details, and maintain constant communication throughout the process. Keller Williams is the largest Brokerage in the World with agents here to assist you in your needs. My free time is spent with my family and the Charity I Co-Founded called IACK (Its About Caring for Kids) which has helped middle income families finances while they are dealing with a gravely ill child. For more info on my wonderful charity, please visit www.iackids.org - in just 5 years we have raised over $1,000,000 and have helped over 100 families pay their bills.

Grant Pettrone
Revolution Real Estate
★★★★★1,600+ sales
Meet Grant Pettrone, Broker/Owner of Revolution Real Estate and Team Leader of The Pettrone Team.A lifelong resident of Western Monroe County, Grant now resides in Spencerport, New York with his family. Grant specializes in the complete rehabilitation of properties for investors and owner-occupants alike. He takes great pride in assisting first-time homebuyers with programs that fit their needs as well as assisting seasoned homeowners with the purchase of their new dream home.Grant's willingness to point out both the pros and cons in every decision throughout the home buying process may be an uncommon style for someone in the real estate profession but it demonstrates his commitment to putting his client’s best interests and needs before everything else. Honesty, respect, loyalty, and integrity are all sacred aspects in both his professional and personal life. Many of our clients have become lifelong friends because that's how we treat anyone that comes to us for guidance in buying a home.Experience real estate the way you deserve to, with Grant on your side!

Craig Schneider
NORCHAR Real Estate
★★★★★1,500+ sales
Craig Schneider epitomizes integrity, energy, hard work and creative service in every detail of your real estate transaction. Craig grew up in Rochester and started his sales habit at the age of ten, selling the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle to the residents of Greece.After 10 years of honorable active military service, Craig resigned from his career as an Electronics Engineer, to pursue his true passion in real estate. He has continued rising early and has since built a successful career as a top producer in the industry.Craig Schneider, Norchar Realty founder, has been a driving force in Rochester's new construction residential real estate sector for more than 15 years. He is recognized as expert in the Pittsford, Penfield, Webster and Henrietta submarkets where he lead the market in sales volume, and where he continues to achieve record-setting sales. His experience derived by being a top producing sales agent for Rochester's largest home builders Ryan Homes Rochester and FABER Homes. Across his markets of expertise, Craig, aside from being very personable, is known for leveraging his strategic negotiation skills, and impressive depth and breadth of market knowledge to his clients' benefit. This has earned him a sterling reputation for collaborating with his impressive network of buyers, sellers, and colleagues to seamlessly close straightforward to complex transactions.Craig is a family man with a devotion to God, his beautiful wife Ann, and two daughters Nora & Charlotte (the company namesakes). He loves the Brighton neighborhood where his family resides and enjoys being part of the Brighton community. Craig enjoys spending time with his family soaking in all of Rochester's art and culture. You are likely to see Craig and his family (including their two dogs Pinky & Glen) at a Brighton Barons game, at any of Rochester's festivals or enjoying after dinner walks around the Cobb's Hill Reservoir. Craig also enjoys photography, cycling, snowboarding, gardening, and singing karaoke with the fam!Craig has been trained and inspired in sales by some of the best from Dale Carnegie, Brian Buffini, Bob Schultz, Brian Tracy, Zig Ziglar, Jim Rohn and others. He is constantly networking with banks and lending institutions to build strong relationships, so that he can offer the Greater Rochester Area the best style loans to meet their needs. Craig uses his experience and foresight to proactively address details before they become a problem. He and his team initiate communication in every detail of the transaction, from the first phone call all the way to close. He leads, trains, and motivates his team to communicate with you better. Five words you can count on from Craig Schneider: love, integrity, commitment, inspiration, and fun.
Paloma Brown
Keller Williams Realty
With over 14 years of real estate experience — including a decade as an investor consultant specializing in home flips — Paloma brings a rare blend of strategy, empathy, and expertise to every client relationship. For buyers, she’s a steadfast advocate and skilled negotiator, focused on securing the best terms and conditions for their long-term goals. Paloma's patience and understanding make all the difference, especially for first-time buyers and those navigating fast-moving or competitive markets. For sellers, Paloma’s edge lies in her strategic emotional intelligence . She helps clients navigate the emotional side of selling while staying laser-focused on results. As she puts it: “Anyone can list your home. I bring something different — emotional intelligence meets market strategy. Clear communication, level-headed guidance, and adaptability under pressure — because great results start with understanding people, not just numbers.”

Mariceli Ortiz
Howard Hanna
With over 15 years of experience in customer service, financial education, and management, I've built my career on helping people reach their goals. I believe buying or selling a home should be exciting, not overwhelming. My priority is to listen, stay available for questions, and make the process as smooth as possible. Deep roots in this community give me the insight and care to lead you to your perfect home.

Nasir Ali
Howard Hanna real Estate
A Realtor you can depend on and trust." My mission is to provide outstanding real estate representation and to deliver results beyond expectations. Allow me to make your real estate experience pleasant and stress free. Howard Hanna & Nasir Ali - MARKETING YOUR HOME FOR MORE MONEY! I'm dedicated to success and helping people in both my personal and professional life. I still live by the same motto for my family and customers: " Treat others the way you would want to be treated." I am truly dedicated to treating people well, and I always have your best
What People Are Saying
“Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.”
Frequently asked questions
- Why hire a top real estate agent in Monroe County, NY?
- Whether you are buying or selling across Monroe County, NY, working with a proven local agent matters. The top real estate agents in Monroe County, NY help sellers net more and close faster, and help buyers save on average thousands of dollars per purchase.
- How does Agent Fixup choose agents in Monroe County, NY?
- We rank the real estate agents serving Monroe County, NY across multiple metrics — past sales, verified reviews, and overall experience — and recommend who fits your move best. Our approach is unbiased; we surface only top performers.
- What does it cost to use Agent Fixup in Monroe County, NY?
- Agent Fixup is free for buyers and sellers in Monroe County, NY. We are paid a referral fee by the agent only after a successful closing, so there is no cost or obligation to you.
Ready to find the right agent in Monroe County, NY?
Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.
Compare Agents