Agent FixupFind an Agent

We found 22 producing agents in Pickaway County, OH

We analyze local sales records and verified reviews across Pickaway County, OH to match you with the top real estate agents in the county. Free for buyers and sellers.

Top real estate agents in Pickaway County, OH

Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

David Allen

David Allen

Key Realty

502+ sales

My name is David M. Allen, and I am a local real estate professional with Key Realty in the Columbus, OH area. I have been in the industry for 20 years, and have worked with hundreds of home Buyers and Sellers in accomplishing all of their real estate goals and dreams. Whether it's finding your first "starter" home, upsizing to a larger home, downsizing to a smaller home, getting rid of that "headache" rental property, etc., I can help! I consistently rank in the top 3% of Columbus real estate professionals, and do business around the entire Columbus area. In case you are interested, I have >100 past client reviews on Zillow.com . Summary Representation of home Buyers and Sellers in real estate transactions. Extensive marketing/promotion/advertising of Client properties listed for sale. * Owner/Manager of Allen Realty Pros - A real estate rental company founded in 2004. * Residential Property Manager * Expired listing specialist * Real estate economist - Specializing in effective property pricing strategies, real estate markets and cycles. Specialties Home Buyers and Sellers, investment property, property management, expired listings. Experience *Real Estate Consultant/Realtor Key Realty September 2018 - Present Keller Williams Consultants Realty March 2010 – September 2018 *Owner/Manager Avid Asset Real Estate April 2004 –Present Education Indiana University of Pennsylvania Bachelor's Business/Real Estate 1995 – 1999 Activities and Societies: Phi Kappa Phi Honors Society

Julie Carter

Julie Carter

Key Realty

500+ sales

Meet Julie Carter – Your Trusted Real Estate Professional in Fayette County, Ohio Julie Carter brings a wealth of experience, dedication, and passion to the world of real estate. Julie relocated to Fayette County, Ohio in 2007 from Atlanta Georgia, embracing the charm of small-town living in her husband’s hometown of Washington Court House. With strong connections to the local community, Julie has built a life and career centered around service, trust, and lasting relationships. Julie attended University of Phoenix, where she studied Business Administration and developed a strong foundation in organizational leadership, strategic planning, and customer service—skills that have proven invaluable throughout her professional journey. After college, she spent several years working in human resources and management roles for large corporations, gaining insights into team building, negotiation, and client satisfaction. Her journey into real estate began in 2000, when she served as a General Manager for an executive suite company. In this role, Julie discovered her love for helping clients find spaces that met their unique needs. That passion naturally led her into residential real estate sales in 2002, where she quickly found success in Atlanta’s dynamic and competitive housing market. Julie thrived in the fast-paced environment, honing her skills in market analysis, home staging, contract negotiation, and client advocacy. After moving to rural Ohio with her husband to raise their two children, Julie seamlessly transitioned her real estate expertise to the local market. She fell in love with the character and history of the area and even took on the personal project of restoring her own 1870 Italianate home in Washington Court House. That experience further deepened her appreciation for historic properties, craftsmanship, and the importance of preserving the beauty and value of a home. Julie is more than just a real estate agent—she is a true partner in your home buying or selling journey. Her clients often praise her for her exceptional communication, responsiveness, and ability to make the process smooth and stress-free. Whether she’s working with first-time homebuyers, seasoned sellers, or real estate investors, Julie approaches every transaction with integrity, professionalism, and a genuine desire to help her clients succeed. Her deep knowledge of the local market, combined with her business background and personal investment in the community, gives her clients a unique advantage. Julie specializes in residential real estate, including single-family homes, investment properties, historic homes, and more. She takes the time to listen, understand your goals, and tailor her services to meet your specific needs. When she’s not working with clients, Julie enjoys spending time with her family, working on home restoration projects, and contributing to the Washington Court House community. Whether you're buying your first home, selling your current one, or looking to invest in local real estate, Julie Carter is ready to provide the expert guidance and personal attention you deserve. Reach out to Julie today—your dream home in Fayette County could be just a phone call away.

Robert Mack

Robert Mack

Keller Williams Consultants Realty

75+ sales

I’m a dedicated, results-driven REALTOR® serving Southeast Ohio (Athens County) and Central Ohio (Columbus). I cover areas from Meigs to Delaware, Licking, Muskingum, Pickaway, and Ross counties. As a member of multiple MLS boards, I provide expanded market access and data-driven strategies to help my clients buy and sell with confidence. Since becoming an individual agent, I’ve consistently closed multimillions in sales annually and was honored with the Ohio Association of REALTORS® 2020 President’s Sales Award as a rookie agent. I’m known for my strong work ethic, responsiveness, and commitment to doing what’s best for every client. I'm a proud father of two daughters and great husband to an amazing partner. Originally from South Carolina, I earned a Bachelor of Science from the University of South Carolina and bring a background in management and finance that strengthens my negotiation and problem-solving skills to the great state of OHIO. I believe real estate is one of the most important financial decisions a person can make, and I take pride in guiding clients with honesty, clarity, and care.

What People Are Saying

Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.

Frequently asked questions

Why hire a top real estate agent in Pickaway County, OH?
Whether you are buying or selling across Pickaway County, OH, working with a proven local agent matters. The top real estate agents in Pickaway County, OH help sellers net more and close faster, and help buyers save on average thousands of dollars per purchase.
How does Agent Fixup choose agents in Pickaway County, OH?
We rank the real estate agents serving Pickaway County, OH across multiple metrics — past sales, verified reviews, and overall experience — and recommend who fits your move best. Our approach is unbiased; we surface only top performers.
What does it cost to use Agent Fixup in Pickaway County, OH?
Agent Fixup is free for buyers and sellers in Pickaway County, OH. We are paid a referral fee by the agent only after a successful closing, so there is no cost or obligation to you.

Ready to find the right agent in Pickaway County, OH?

Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.

Compare Agents

Cities in Pickaway County, OH