Agent FixupFind an Agent

We found 22 producing agents in Shelby County, OH

We analyze local sales records and verified reviews across Shelby County, OH to match you with the top real estate agents in the county. Free for buyers and sellers.

Top real estate agents in Shelby County, OH

Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

Jonathan Murray

Jonathan Murray

Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate

★★★★★2,000+ sales

As a child, Jon was raised on a small farm in Lewisburg where he learned the value of hard work. Jon learned discipline and how to overcome adversity while he was a standout athlete at Tri-County North High School. While Jon was in high school, he worked in residential construction, building and remodeling houses. Helping to advise buyers and sellers on updating and remodeling projects turned out to be the perfect catalyst for Jon's real estate career. After high school, Jon attended Ohio Northern University where he earned a Bachelor of Science degree in Exercise Physiology. While at Ohio Northern, Jon was on the varsity football team as well the indoor and outdoor track teams. In addition, while at Ohio Northern, Jon was one of the top ranked power lifters in the world. After college, he worked in his field for a year and received several high paying job offers in New York. Jon loves the Miami Valley and just could not imagine moving away. So to have a stable income, Jon went back to building and remodeling houses where he became the foreman for AK Construction. While working in the construction field, Jon enjoyed the daily interaction with people who were considering building houses. When his boss started buying properties and fixing them up and selling them or renting them, Jon became motivated to purchase his own fixer upper house to renovate on the side. He enjoyed this type of work tremendously. Jon realized that if he got his real estate license, he could have better access to find the deals for himself and his boss. Jon went back to school and obtained his real estate license with the intention of just representing himself and family and friends. While renovating a house one weekend, Jon seriously injured his back on the job site. Since Jon could not physically work on houses anymore, he was forced to make the decision to work as a Realtor full time. Within a short period of time, Jon was so busy helping others buy and sell real estate that he never went back to work building houses. Within a year or so, Jon was representing so many buyers, sellers, and other investors that he stopped working on houses all together. Getting into real estate was a great decision for Jon because he has been one of the top agents in the area for several years and he and his partner were the top two agents in the entire company in 2009. Jon's honesty and unparalleled work ethic have made his past clients loyal supporters who tell everyone that they have to use Jon because he is the best Realtor they've ever worked with. Jon now lives in Kettering with his wife Jena who was his high school sweet heart. Living with them are their daughters: Paige and twins, Tessa and Talia.

Tami Holmes

Tami Holmes

Cutler Real Estate

★★★★★2,000+ sales

Service YOU deserve.........from people YOU trust!We look forward to earning your trust and respect through our 'on-call' level of service and our extensive local knowledge.We invite you to put our Experts to the test.We sell a home every day! That means that you will be assisted with your real estate needs by professionals who are the most experienced in the market. Team members receive continuous training in all aspects of real estate so you receive representation from true professionals who know their craft like no others. You have seen us featured on NBC, CBS, ABC, WHIO, and WHKO. Star of ABC's Shark Tank and real estate guru Barbara Corcoran trusts us and recommends us to sell your home. Nancy on K99.1 has recommended us for years for all your real estate needs. Tami Holmes Real Estate Team specializes in all of Southwest Ohio including Dayton, Cincinnati and Troy real estate. We love the Southwest Ohio area! We're passionate about the real estate market here.We have an amazing Team of Real Estate Experts. We are confident that they will deliver world-class service. In addition to our Team Leader Tami, our Experts include Jody Canupp, Traci Stoll, Jason Mathews, Bekah Mathews, Terry Mull, Haley Rose, Beth Workman, Jim Schemel, Taylor Smith, and Katelyn Sandberg.Happy House Hunting!

Rita OLeary

Rita OLeary

Coldwell Banker Heritage Realtor

★★★★★300+ sales

Welcome! Personalized customer service is not a thing of the past with me! Buying or selling? IT'S ALL ABOUT YOU!! I am a full time Ohio licensed agent available 24/7, offering you professional and sincere service for Huber Heights, Beavercreek, Vandalia, Tipp City, Kettering, Forest Ridge, Dayton & surrounding areas. My philosophy is to be ethical, be trustworthy, be available and listen to my clients. Throughout my career, I've been recognized as:-A Multi-Million Dollar Producer! -2003-2018 Top 50 Coldwell Banker Heritage Realtor Agent-2003-2018 Ohio Association of Realtors (OAR) Presidents Sales Club -2003-2007 & 2009-2018 Dayton Area Board of Realtors Sales Leader -2003-2018 Coldwell Banker's International Diamond Society; achieved by only the -top 9% of more than 127,000 sales associates worldwide in the Coldwell Banker system.-2005, Became Senior Sales Associate with Coldwell Banker, 2011 Became Associate Partner Life's other pleasures include 2 grandsons, boating with my son & family and my 5 lb DIVA Maltese "Olivia". Interested in learning more about my services or your next steps? Please text or call me at (937) 620-5026, or send me an email at rita.oleary@coldwellbanker.com. Remember, It's not about the Years in your Life but the Life in your Years . Let me help you get back to LIVING by making your transaction simple and straightforward! I look forward to hearing from you!

What People Are Saying

Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.

Frequently asked questions

Why hire a top real estate agent in Shelby County, OH?
Whether you are buying or selling across Shelby County, OH, working with a proven local agent matters. The top real estate agents in Shelby County, OH help sellers net more and close faster, and help buyers save on average thousands of dollars per purchase.
How does Agent Fixup choose agents in Shelby County, OH?
We rank the real estate agents serving Shelby County, OH across multiple metrics — past sales, verified reviews, and overall experience — and recommend who fits your move best. Our approach is unbiased; we surface only top performers.
What does it cost to use Agent Fixup in Shelby County, OH?
Agent Fixup is free for buyers and sellers in Shelby County, OH. We are paid a referral fee by the agent only after a successful closing, so there is no cost or obligation to you.

Ready to find the right agent in Shelby County, OH?

Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.

Compare Agents

Cities in Shelby County, OH