We found 88 highly-rated agents in Crystal Lake, IL
We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to match you with the top real estate agents in Crystal Lake. Free for buyers and sellers.

Top real estate agents in Crystal Lake, IL
Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

ERIKA VARGASPreferred
Realty of America
My name is Erika Vargas, happily married and proud mother of 3 grown up kids, I am a Real Estate Agent Broker for Residential, Commercial and Investment. Experienced helping Buyers, Sellers, and Investors achieve their real estate goals. I am proudly affiliated with Realty of America (Roa), which allows me to provide strong professional support and a smooth, well-managed transaction experience. I specialize in helping clients upsize, downsize, and work with investment properties, including home flippers. I am committed to clear communication, personalized service, and making every transaction stress-free. Hablo Español, and I am happy to assist clients in their preferred language.

Shreena JobePreferred
Keller Williams Realty
Raised in the Northwest Suburbs, Shreena brings more than 15 years of expertise in sales, client management, and building meaningful relationships. Her warm communication style and natural ability to guide others make her a trusted advocate for clients at every step of their home‑buying, selling, or renting journey. Known for her honesty, integrity, and genuine commitment to understanding each client’s goals, Shreena ensures every experience is personalized, transparent, and stress free. Her clients appreciate her thoughtful approach, strong attention to detail, and unwavering dedication to helping them make confident decisions. Outside of real estate, Shreena is a proud wife and mom of two, a passionate foodie, devoted yogi, and plant enthusiast. Shreena believes a home is more than a place, it’s where memories are created, families grow, and life truly unfolds.

Shannon Bremner
Keller Williams Success Realty
★★★★★430+ sales
Shannon BremnerKeller Williams Success RealtyShannon's goal is to build strong relationships with her clients. She will work tirelessly to exceed your expectations; keep you informed and always act with your best interests at heart. Shannon has been a longtime resident of the Chicagoland area and knows the market well. Shannon's background in management taught her how to set goals, create a plan and research her competition. She has strong analytical skills, is a Certified Staging Consultant and a Seniors Real Estate Specialist. Shannon consistently sells over 50 homes a year and ended 2020 +22% in sales over last year. She's a member of the Chamber of Commerce and serves on the Agent Leadership Council (ALC) with Keller Williams. A position of honor for top producing agents. Shannon is delighted to discuss any questions or concerns you may have regarding today's market and the wonderful opportunities it presents! Whether you're looking to buy, sell or invest in real estate, Shannon Bremner's goal is to deliver a smooth and (financially) rewarding transaction. She's looking forward to the opportunity to earn your business.When Shannon Bremner isn't working, she can be found traveling and spending time with her two children. She adores having the flexibility in her schedule to attend their track and cross country meets and serves on the board of the Cary-Grove Track & Cross Country Association. However, when it comes time to list or buy a new home, she's all business! Shannon is a true advocate for her clients.

Barbara Gorecki
HomeSmart Connect
300+ sales
I am highly seasoned agent whose vast experience and familiarity of the changing market I will guide you through every step of your transaction. Dedicated to providing personalized service and attention to your specific wants and needs. An innovate thinker with unsurpassed marketing tools to provide impeccable service in even the most complex real estate transaction. Sound advice given through knowledge and experience.

Mandy Montford
Baird & Warner
★★★★★260+ sales
Thank you for finding me, I'm glad you're here! I am a market expert in the Crystal Lake, Lakewood and greater McHenry County area. I have lived here for 40+ years, and am intimately familiar with our neighborhoods, schools, and area amenities. When choosing an agent, having a true local market expert is crucial.Clients appreciate my work ethic, creativity, honesty, strategic thinking, and consistent communication. I work tirelessly for my clients to make sure they have the best possible experience.My background in executive sales and online marketing gives me a firm footing for selling homes. Additionally, as a Certified Staging Consultant and a Certified Negotiation Expert, I have the necessary tools to make sure your home is seen in the best light, and help negotiate effectively when the right offer comes in. Staging homes is an important part of my skill set that has enabled my sellers to achieve sale prices that they never thought were possible. My personal experience as a real estate investor has been an asset when helping clients assess homes from a long-term investment perspective. A new home should not only meet your lifestyle needs, but also be wealth creating.My broad network of professional partners enables me to make life easier for my clients. From lenders, to home inspectors, contractors, movers, and attorneys, I have trusted, experienced partners to help you along the way.Here are a few data points about my career in residential home sales:1) #1 Sales Producer in the Baird & Warner Far Northwest Office, 20192) Baird & Warner Founders' Club recipient 2018, 2019, 2020, 2021, 20222) In the past rolling 12 months, my listings have sold in an average of 3 days, at 103% of list price. This is a result of thorough preparation, pricing, and good negotiation.4) I have done 250% more transactions in the past year than the average Realtor in our market area. This keeps me in touch with the 'pulse' of the market and facilitates great working relationships with other area agents, which in turn, benefits my clients.5) When you hire me for your real estate needs, you get ME. I intentionally do not work with a team, as I don't want to send a rookie to represent you in important decisions. If you choose to work with me, it's probably due to my experience and expertise. I want to honor your decision and give you my best.I'd love to hear from you!815.245.8195 MandyDegrees, Certifications and Associations:- BA, Northwestern University, Economics- Founder's Club, Baird & Warner- Certified Staging Consultant- Certified Negotiation Expert- National and Illinois Associations of Realtors- Crystal Lake Chamber of Commerce- Councilwoman, Crystal Lake City Council- Heartland Realtor Organization
Dustin Delaney
HomeSmart
56+ sales
My name is Dustin and I have been in real estate for over 21 years. I have experience in rehabbing homes as well working close with buyers to find the best home for them. Working with me you will get someone that will do what ever it takes to help you out, I will never be salesy to you. Buying a home is a huge purchase and you will know when you find the right house is, not me. My job is to help you find the house not sell you on a house you do not like.

Sam Kuch
Coldwell Banker
Sam Kuch is a dedicated and passionate Real Estate Broker at Coldwell Banker Realty. Specializing in working with buyers and sellers for residential properties, Sam’s enthusiasm and commitment to helping clients find their dream homes are evident in every interaction. Real estate has been a long-standing passion for Sam, and this drive fuels his desire to build strong relationships with every client.
Shane Vetter
Coldwell Banker Realty
Over a decade of helping buyers and sellers with their needs by understanding their motivation and goals and then through consultative and education approaches we come together to create the best marketing solution to sell their home or the best strategy to make them look like the strongest buyer they can be as we customize a thorough search to not waster their times and to help them find the home that meets their needs in the proper timeframe they require.
What People Are Saying
“Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.”
How Agent Fixup works in Crystal Lake, IL
- 1
Tell us about your home
Share a few quick details about your property and goals in Crystal Lake — it takes about a minute.
- 2
We match you with top agents
We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to surface the best-fit agents in Crystal Lake.
- 3
Compare and choose
Review profiles and commission estimates, then connect — free, with no obligation.
What’s your home worth in Crystal Lake?
Get a free home value estimate and connect with a top Crystal Lake agent — no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
- Why is it important to hire a top real estate agent in Crystal Lake?
- Whether you are buying or selling a house or condo in Crystal Lake, it is important to use a real estate agent with proven experience. The top real estate agents in Crystal Lake help home owners sell their home for more money and faster. The top real estate buyer agents in Crystal Lake help save their clients on average thousands of dollars every purchase.
- When should I hire a real estate agent from Crystal Lake?
- The best time to hire a real estate agent in Crystal Lake is roughly 3-6 months from the time you plan to purchase a home. A top real estate agent should provide you with market updates and new homes to market.
- What commission do real estate agents charge in Crystal Lake?
- The average commission real estate seller's agents work for in Crystal Lake is 3%, although commissions vary from agent to agent and city to city.
- How does Agent Fixup help me find a real estate agent in Crystal Lake?
- Agent Fixup finds the top real estate agents in Crystal Lake and recommends who would be your best fit based off past sales, reviews and overall experience. We take an unbiased approach to finding you only the top real estate agents in Crystal Lake.
- How do real estate agents join Agent Fixup in Crystal Lake?
- Our real estate agents in Crystal Lake are mostly hand selected. We have a selective process which includes interviewing each agent and learning their past experience and goals for the coming year.
- How does Agent Fixup decide which agents to use in Crystal Lake?
- Agent Fixup uses many metrics to choose which agents to use in Crystal Lake. We look for traits of top agents including how many listings the agent has sold in the past years that have been over asking price as well as how much they save their buyers and sellers on average. Superior market knowledge is always a must for us.
Ready to find the right agent in Crystal Lake, IL?
Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.
Compare Agents