Agent Fixup

We found 110 producing agents in Fishers, IN

We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to match you with the top real estate agents in Fishers. Free for buyers and sellers.

A local real estate agent showing a home to a family in Fishers, IN

Top real estate agents in Fishers, IN

Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

Peter Stewart

Peter StewartPreferred

Keller Williams Realty

915+ sales

With an unwavering commitment to excellence, Peter has been a driving force in the real estate industry since 2009. He is the #1 individual agent at the KW Carmel office and the #1 investor focused broker in the city, with over a quarter billion dollars in career sales. Specializing in assisting clients with buying, selling, and investing in real estate, Peter is never content with anything less than impeccable results and total satisfaction. Armed with a background in entrepreneurship and an impressive sales track record, Peter possesses the business acumen and nuanced understanding of the real estate market needed to champion his clients' needs and consistently produce outstanding results. A dynamic and passionate professional, Peter is dedicated to creating win-win situations for all his clients. He approaches business with a serious mindset while infusing every interaction with a positive attitude and a sense of humor. Beyond his role as a real estate broker, Peter has been an avid real estate investor since 2011, owning a diverse portfolio of properties across the country. Outside the realm of real estate, Peter finds joy in spending time with his wife and two children at his Carmel home. An enthusiast of fitness and nutrition, he is a regular participant in marathons, obstacle course races, duathlons, triathlons, and various outdoor events across the country. Peter's commitment extends beyond the real estate realm, reflecting a well-rounded professional dedicated to both the success of his clients and the pursuit of a fulfilling personal life.

Curtis  Holland

Curtis HollandPreferred

United Real Estate Indy

53+ sales

FALL IN LOVE. LIVE YOUR DEAM. Our team was founded on providing not only excellent customer service during a transaction, but because our years of Service experience, it has allowed us to build a comprehensive list of trusted contractors and service providers we can refer to our past clients years after they’ve closed. Hiring the best Realty company to represent your interests (both financially and personally) should not be taken lightly. We take this commitment seriously and we will work tirelessly for you. We offer free staging, professional, magazine quality photos, and intensive social media marketing with all of our listings to help bring you top dollar for your home. “Our promise: We will move heaven and earth to find the perfect house for our buyers. As for our sellers we offer gorgeous staging, professional photography and DAILY paid Facebook advertising FOR FREE to our sellers! We know that today’s home-buyer starts their search online, so our first step is to make irresistible photos. Our next goal is to make buyers walk into our listings and think: I will be MISERABLE if I don’t get this house. LOL. Seriously, though, our success has been built on the magical trinity of FREE staging, photos and marketing. The formula works: Most of our listings have accepted offers in less than a week, often in 48 hours! Metro Indy Home Real Estate Group with United Real Estate Indianapolis.”

Jim Trueblood

Jim Trueblood

Trueblood Real Estate

★★★★★5,600+ sales

After family and friends, real estate has always been my passion. With the help of my grandfather, I purchased my first rental home at just 16 years old. I have continued to buy, sell, and manage properties ever since. Upon graduating from business school at Purdue University in 2003, a career in real estate became my goal. My professional career began as a purchasing manager at a lumber yard then transitioned into a sales and project management position for a custom home builder before becoming a licensed broker.For the past thirteen years, helping clients sell and purchases properties in the Greater Indianapolis area has been my business. Recently, my team has expanded to all of Central Indiana and the Lafayette/West Lafayette area. Having gone through the buying and selling process many times myself, combined with my experience in construction and development, I am able to provide a unique and successful experience for my clients. With the number one goal of client satisfaction, our team has developed a comprehensive Internet marketing system which has propelled us to be one of the top real estate sales teams in Central Indiana. In the Fall of 2018, Trueblood Real Estate brokerage was launched. Moving forward, this will allow us to continue to grow and provide an even better service for our clients. Real Estate is what I truly love, and I could not imagine doing anything else. I look forward to providing the best customer experience and helping clients reach their own real estate goals.

Eric Forney

Eric Forney

Livian - Catalyst

★★★★★1,800+ sales

Finding the right real estate agent means finding someone who possesses extensive market knowledge, delivers outstanding client satisfaction, and is committed to always negotiating with your best interests in mind. I am able to provide you all of that and more by helping you manage the details of your transaction, and navigate the often overwhelming real estate market. My commitment to delivering an outstanding level of client service, my relentless work ethic, and an extensive background in negotiation skills, allow me to deliver unparalleled results and maximize the financial impact of your home.As a business owner and investor I understand the importance of creative marketing, prompt follow up with a purpose, and maximizing profit margins by differentiating myself and my clients from competitors. Whether you are an experienced investor or a first time buyer, I can help you with the property of your dreams. Please feel free to browse my website or let me guide you every step of the way by calling or e-mailing me to set up an appointment today.

Shannon Gilbert

Shannon Gilbert

Highgarden Real Estate

★★★★★1,400+ sales

Shannon Gilbert is dedicated to customized real estate marketing and service excellence. Whether you are buying or selling a home, interested in new construction or foreclosures, you will benefit from a more personalized approach and marketing strategies tailored to meet your specific needs.Ranked in the top 25 agents in the state of Indiana, her knowledge and experience can help you more effectively achieve your real estate goals. Shannon sells homes all over the Indianapolis area with a strong focus in Hamilton County. She started her real estate journey in 2009 and in 2014 she formed The Gilbert Group. Over the years many agents have had the opportunity to train under The Gilbert Group but two agents have truly emerged as leaders. Dawna Ridgeway, fresh into real estate, came on in 2016 with Jamie Ball following in 2017. Working side by side for over 6 years they are now known in the industry as a team that produces results for not only their clients but also their fellow agents. The girls are supported by Addison Altum, who runs the back end of the business, an in-house stager and a full marketing staff. This has allowed them to dedicate more time to market research and strategic online marketing for their listings.Shannon has a passion for technology and a knack for staying ahead of the curve in the real estate market. Her expertise in the industry helped her become the TOP MIBOR agent for lowest days on market in 2020 at 17 days. She is highly ranked in customer services across all of the most popular real estate platforms. Her client reviews reveal her personable nature, strong industry/area knowledge and quick response time.Personal facts about Shannon: Originally for Northwest Indiana, she graduated from Purdue University and moved to the Indianapolis area settling down in Boone County. In 2009 she built a home in Noblesville, settling there until 2012 to move to Fishers. As a single mom of two girls, Grace and Claire, her life is always busy and on the go. She is involved at Fall Creek Intermediate and Junior High where the girls attend school. Her kids are active in organized sports in Fishers and she loves to be a part of the community. You may see her walking around town with her two Vizsla's, Chance and Cooper. She has a passion for life, with family and career being her main focus.

Stephanie Marshall

Stephanie Marshall

eXp Realty

Real estate is more than transactions to me—it’s about helping people make decisions that shape their lives. I’m Stephanie Renee, a licensed real estate professional who believes buying or selling a home should feel clear, supported, and intentional, not rushed or overwhelming. I take a thoughtful, strategic approach to real estate—one rooted in honest communication, strong advocacy, and respect for your goals. I understand that real estate decisions often come during pivotal life moments—new beginnings, transitions, growth, or change. That’s why I focus on guidance over pressure and clarity over chaos. My role is to help you understand your options, ask the right questions, and move forward with confidence—whether you’re buying your first home, selling a property, or planning your next step. What sets me apart is how I show up for my clients. I listen closely, communicate clearly, and stay fully engaged from our first conversation through closing. I combine market knowledge with strong people skills, ensuring you feel informed, respected, and supported every step of the way. I don’t believe in one-size-fits-all real estate. I believe in personalized strategy, transparency, and doing things the right way—even when it takes a little more care. If you’re looking for a real estate professional who is grounded, strategic, and genuinely invested in your success, I’d be honored to work with you.

What People Are Saying

Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.

How Agent Fixup works in Fishers, IN

  1. 1

    Tell us about your home

    Share a few quick details about your property and goals in Fishers — it takes about a minute.

  2. 2

    We match you with top agents

    We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to surface the best-fit agents in Fishers.

  3. 3

    Compare and choose

    Review profiles and commission estimates, then connect — free, with no obligation.

What’s your home worth in Fishers?

Get a free home value estimate and connect with a top Fishers agent — no obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it important to hire a top real estate agent in Fishers?
Whether you are buying or selling a house or condo in Fishers, it is important to use a real estate agent with proven experience. The top real estate agents in Fishers help home owners sell their home for more money and faster. The top real estate buyer agents in Fishers help save their clients on average thousands of dollars every purchase.
When should I hire a real estate agent from Fishers?
The best time to hire a real estate agent in Fishers is roughly 3-6 months from the time you plan to purchase a home. A top real estate agent should provide you with market updates and new homes to market.
What commission do real estate agents charge in Fishers?
The average commission real estate seller's agents work for in Fishers is 3%, although commissions vary from agent to agent and city to city.
How does Agent Fixup help me find a real estate agent in Fishers?
Agent Fixup finds the top real estate agents in Fishers and recommends who would be your best fit based off past sales, reviews and overall experience. We take an unbiased approach to finding you only the top real estate agents in Fishers.
How do real estate agents join Agent Fixup in Fishers?
Our real estate agents in Fishers are mostly hand selected. We have a selective process which includes interviewing each agent and learning their past experience and goals for the coming year.
How does Agent Fixup decide which agents to use in Fishers?
Agent Fixup uses many metrics to choose which agents to use in Fishers. We look for traits of top agents including how many listings the agent has sold in the past years that have been over asking price as well as how much they save their buyers and sellers on average. Superior market knowledge is always a must for us.

Ready to find the right agent in Fishers, IN?

Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.

Compare Agents

Browse agents from other cities in Indiana