Agent Fixup

We found 57 producing agents in Ithaca, NY

We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to match you with the top real estate agents in Ithaca. Free for buyers and sellers.

A local real estate agent showing a home to a family in Ithaca, NY

Top real estate agents in Ithaca, NY

Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

Jolene Rightmyer Macolini

Jolene Rightmyer Macolini

Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Heritage Realty

★★★★★1,100+ sales

A true real estate professional and a Tompkins County native.Jolene Rightmyer Macolini has been serving clients since 2003 as a top-producing Realtor®.-- As a Realtor, I never forget that real estate is not about wheeling and dealing -- it’s about home, community, and helping my clients meet their personal and financial goals.Jolene’s honesty, integrity, market knowledge, reputation, and trustworthiness, havealways been the foundation of her real estate success.-- I’m here to make your sale or purchase as easy and stress-free as possible -- and to help you feel right at home.Jolene enjoys walking Sellers through the often-complicated selling process and safeguarding a smooth transition. Her expertise is in pricing the home competitively, strategically marketing to potential buyers, listening to the needs of the clients, andselling the home within a specific timeframe, all designed with the Seller’s needs in mind.Jolene’s background in professional Staging helps to ensure a better outcome in the sale. Using all the best technology, top-notch photographers, creative descriptions, social media platforms, 3D tours, and floorplans bring award-quality representationto the home.This experience carries over to her work with Buyers. Jolene guides them through the process every step of the way. Buyers can sleep well at night knowing that with Jolene they can write a competitive contract and secure the home of their dreams at thebest possible price!Knowledgeable – Experienced – CaringCall on me for the best insights, advice, and guidance.-----------------------------------------------------AWARDS & RECOGNITIONSHoward Hanna's Top Producing Team in the Southern Tier of NY 2015-PresentHoward Hanna's National Sales Excellence 2015 - presentHoward Hanna's Circle of Excellence 2017- presentIthaca Board of Realtors Top Producing Team 2017- presentReal Trends Top Real Estate Team in New York 2016 - present

Claudia Lagalla

Claudia Lagalla

Howard Hanna Real Estate

★★★★★500+ sales

Professional. Kind. Warm. Honest. Intuitive. Creative. Innovative. A good listener and a skilled advocate at the negotiating table. This is how clients describe Claudia Lagalla.In 268 Zillow reviews (and counting), clients have wholeheartedly recommended her, and expressed unreserved confidence. Those reviews combined with several hundred past closings provides absolute proof of Claudia's ability to skillfully advise and guide you. In the last several years she has assisted more buyers than any other Ithaca area agent (many first time buyers). Moreover, sellers have time and again expressed their delight with her dedication to their goals.To what does she attribute her success and her clients' satisfaction? "I take my clients' goals to heart; it's my responsibility to help them achieve their goals while protecting them, and guiding them on what is for most the largest investment they will ever make. I commit myself to giving my all to every client."A graduate of NYC H.S. of Music and Art, a degree in jewelry design from the FIT, an Alfred U BA in poli sci, and 20 years' experience in marketing at NYC's top investment banks, equips her with a wealth of experience. Past experience, unbridled drive, energy and enthusiasm are just part of what has contributed to her significant achievements on behalf of her clients. Add to that an innate talent that just can't be taught; an ability to understand and find ways to help people achieve their goals. "For me real estate is not sales – it's guidance; it's about understanding the needs of my clients, and providing them with good solid guidance and advice. I view my role as counselor, and trusted adviser."In what remains of her time, Claudia enjoys social dancing of all kinds, from zydeco to swing, gardening, time with family, and her canine companions.New to the area? Ithaca and its surrounding towns and counties are known for their abundant natural beauty, for a multitude of waterfalls tumbling into Cayuga Lake, state parks, music, theater, arts, farmers' markets, wineries, restaurants, for intellectual vigor, and youthful exuberance.Ithaca has been ranked one of the best in several quality of life categories:• America's number one emerging city• Top college town in the U.S.• One of the two most eco-friendly cities in the nation• One of the five best places to buy a retirement home• One of America's five best mountain biking towns• America's most enlightened city and one of sixty best American Public Places.No wonder you're considering moving here!Call Claudia now so you can begin the work of fulfilling your real estate goals and dreams: 607-342-3749, or email me today at homes@clagalla.com.

Havana Jorrin

Havana Jorrin

Warren Real Estate

★★★★★100+ sales

Find Havana on HGTV's LAKE FRONT BARGIN HUNT! The Season 10 premiere episode features Havana finding a beautiful lake front property on Cayuga lake for her Buyers. She has many testimonials here is one: "Absolutely one of the best experiences I have ever had working with a real estate agent. She is kind, hardworking and honest, taking time to carefully find just what it is that suits you. She is thoughtful, and will even advise against something that might not be the right fit. A gem of person, she is not only professionally stellar, but has personal integrity. A true rarity. Could not more highly recommend her! "

What People Are Saying

Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.

How Agent Fixup works in Ithaca, NY

  1. 1

    Tell us about your home

    Share a few quick details about your property and goals in Ithaca — it takes about a minute.

  2. 2

    We match you with top agents

    We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to surface the best-fit agents in Ithaca.

  3. 3

    Compare and choose

    Review profiles and commission estimates, then connect — free, with no obligation.

What’s your home worth in Ithaca?

Get a free home value estimate and connect with a top Ithaca agent — no obligation.

Frequently asked questions

Why is it important to hire a top real estate agent in Ithaca?
Whether you are buying or selling a house or condo in Ithaca, it is important to use a real estate agent with proven experience. The top real estate agents in Ithaca help home owners sell their home for more money and faster. The top real estate buyer agents in Ithaca help save their clients on average thousands of dollars every purchase.
When should I hire a real estate agent from Ithaca?
The best time to hire a real estate agent in Ithaca is roughly 3-6 months from the time you plan to purchase a home. A top real estate agent should provide you with market updates and new homes to market.
What commission do real estate agents charge in Ithaca?
The average commission real estate seller's agents work for in Ithaca is 3%, although commissions vary from agent to agent and city to city.
How does Agent Fixup help me find a real estate agent in Ithaca?
Agent Fixup finds the top real estate agents in Ithaca and recommends who would be your best fit based off past sales, reviews and overall experience. We take an unbiased approach to finding you only the top real estate agents in Ithaca.
How do real estate agents join Agent Fixup in Ithaca?
Our real estate agents in Ithaca are mostly hand selected. We have a selective process which includes interviewing each agent and learning their past experience and goals for the coming year.
How does Agent Fixup decide which agents to use in Ithaca?
Agent Fixup uses many metrics to choose which agents to use in Ithaca. We look for traits of top agents including how many listings the agent has sold in the past years that have been over asking price as well as how much they save their buyers and sellers on average. Superior market knowledge is always a must for us.

Ready to find the right agent in Ithaca, NY?

Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.

Compare Agents

Browse agents from other cities in New York