We found 16 highly-rated agents in Mattoon, IL
We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to match you with the top real estate agents in Mattoon. Free for buyers and sellers.

Top real estate agents in Mattoon, IL
Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

Tom Bariether
Coldwell Banker Classic Real Estate
★★★★★185+ sales
I have been a full-time Realtor since 1997. Being a lifelong resident of Mattoon, property owner, and current farm owner, I have first-hand knowledge of the local real estate market. During my career, I have received the President's Silver Award for sales production, as well as Ruby Sales Level, selected as 2002 Realtor-Associate of the year, and most recently inducted into the Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Foundation Donor Wall for philanthropic leadership in 2017. I have served on the board of directors as well as numerous other committees for the Central Illinois Board of Realtors. I am a member of the Providence Church in Mattoon, a lifetime member of Wabash Lodge #179 AF&AM and the AASR Valley of Danville.

Rose Mary Dalton
Coldwell Banker Classic Real Estate
★★★★★77+ sales
Hello! My true passion is working with people! As a Realtor, my goal is to offer genuine customer service before, during and after the process of buying or selling your home. If you have questions or are ready to start looking for your new home, please feel free to text, call, or email me! I look forward to hearing from you!

Dana Price
Keller Williams Realty
★★★★★53+ sales
It's not easy to find a great Realtor. Look no further.... As a native of Coles County, Dana brings a wealth of knowledge about our community and its attributes. She has a Bachelors Degree from Eastern Illinois University. With a background in Property Management and working with real estate clients, Dana is well suited in making her client's real estate goals a reality. Whether you are looking to buy, sell or rent properties, she can guide you through the process. Dana can be reached at 217-254-4614.
What People Are Saying
“Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.”
How Agent Fixup works in Mattoon, IL
- 1
Tell us about your home
Share a few quick details about your property and goals in Mattoon — it takes about a minute.
- 2
We match you with top agents
We analyze local sales records and verified reviews to surface the best-fit agents in Mattoon.
- 3
Compare and choose
Review profiles and commission estimates, then connect — free, with no obligation.
What’s your home worth in Mattoon?
Get a free home value estimate and connect with a top Mattoon agent — no obligation.
Frequently asked questions
- Why is it important to hire a top real estate agent in Mattoon?
- Whether you are buying or selling a house or condo in Mattoon, it is important to use a real estate agent with proven experience. The top real estate agents in Mattoon help home owners sell their home for more money and faster. The top real estate buyer agents in Mattoon help save their clients on average thousands of dollars every purchase.
- When should I hire a real estate agent from Mattoon?
- The best time to hire a real estate agent in Mattoon is roughly 3-6 months from the time you plan to purchase a home. A top real estate agent should provide you with market updates and new homes to market.
- What commission do real estate agents charge in Mattoon?
- The average commission real estate seller's agents work for in Mattoon is 3%, although commissions vary from agent to agent and city to city.
- How does Agent Fixup help me find a real estate agent in Mattoon?
- Agent Fixup finds the top real estate agents in Mattoon and recommends who would be your best fit based off past sales, reviews and overall experience. We take an unbiased approach to finding you only the top real estate agents in Mattoon.
- How do real estate agents join Agent Fixup in Mattoon?
- Our real estate agents in Mattoon are mostly hand selected. We have a selective process which includes interviewing each agent and learning their past experience and goals for the coming year.
- How does Agent Fixup decide which agents to use in Mattoon?
- Agent Fixup uses many metrics to choose which agents to use in Mattoon. We look for traits of top agents including how many listings the agent has sold in the past years that have been over asking price as well as how much they save their buyers and sellers on average. Superior market knowledge is always a must for us.
Ready to find the right agent in Mattoon, IL?
Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.
Compare Agents