We found 377 producing agents in Hamilton County, IN
We analyze local sales records and verified reviews across Hamilton County, IN to match you with the top real estate agents in the county. Free for buyers and sellers.
Top real estate agents in Hamilton County, IN
Ranked by sales history and verified reviews, preferred partners first.

Peter StewartPreferred
Keller Williams Realty
915+ sales
With an unwavering commitment to excellence, Peter has been a driving force in the real estate industry since 2009. He is the #1 individual agent at the KW Carmel office and the #1 investor focused broker in the city, with over a quarter billion dollars in career sales. Specializing in assisting clients with buying, selling, and investing in real estate, Peter is never content with anything less than impeccable results and total satisfaction. Armed with a background in entrepreneurship and an impressive sales track record, Peter possesses the business acumen and nuanced understanding of the real estate market needed to champion his clients' needs and consistently produce outstanding results. A dynamic and passionate professional, Peter is dedicated to creating win-win situations for all his clients. He approaches business with a serious mindset while infusing every interaction with a positive attitude and a sense of humor. Beyond his role as a real estate broker, Peter has been an avid real estate investor since 2011, owning a diverse portfolio of properties across the country. Outside the realm of real estate, Peter finds joy in spending time with his wife and two children at his Carmel home. An enthusiast of fitness and nutrition, he is a regular participant in marathons, obstacle course races, duathlons, triathlons, and various outdoor events across the country. Peter's commitment extends beyond the real estate realm, reflecting a well-rounded professional dedicated to both the success of his clients and the pursuit of a fulfilling personal life.

Curtis HollandPreferred
United Real Estate Indy
53+ sales
FALL IN LOVE. LIVE YOUR DEAM. Our team was founded on providing not only excellent customer service during a transaction, but because our years of Service experience, it has allowed us to build a comprehensive list of trusted contractors and service providers we can refer to our past clients years after they’ve closed. Hiring the best Realty company to represent your interests (both financially and personally) should not be taken lightly. We take this commitment seriously and we will work tirelessly for you. We offer free staging, professional, magazine quality photos, and intensive social media marketing with all of our listings to help bring you top dollar for your home. “Our promise: We will move heaven and earth to find the perfect house for our buyers. As for our sellers we offer gorgeous staging, professional photography and DAILY paid Facebook advertising FOR FREE to our sellers! We know that today’s home-buyer starts their search online, so our first step is to make irresistible photos. Our next goal is to make buyers walk into our listings and think: I will be MISERABLE if I don’t get this house. LOL. Seriously, though, our success has been built on the magical trinity of FREE staging, photos and marketing. The formula works: Most of our listings have accepted offers in less than a week, often in 48 hours! Metro Indy Home Real Estate Group with United Real Estate Indianapolis.”

Jim Trueblood
Trueblood Real Estate
★★★★★5,600+ sales
After family and friends, real estate has always been my passion. With the help of my grandfather, I purchased my first rental home at just 16 years old. I have continued to buy, sell, and manage properties ever since. Upon graduating from business school at Purdue University in 2003, a career in real estate became my goal. My professional career began as a purchasing manager at a lumber yard then transitioned into a sales and project management position for a custom home builder before becoming a licensed broker.For the past thirteen years, helping clients sell and purchases properties in the Greater Indianapolis area has been my business. Recently, my team has expanded to all of Central Indiana and the Lafayette/West Lafayette area. Having gone through the buying and selling process many times myself, combined with my experience in construction and development, I am able to provide a unique and successful experience for my clients. With the number one goal of client satisfaction, our team has developed a comprehensive Internet marketing system which has propelled us to be one of the top real estate sales teams in Central Indiana. In the Fall of 2018, Trueblood Real Estate brokerage was launched. Moving forward, this will allow us to continue to grow and provide an even better service for our clients. Real Estate is what I truly love, and I could not imagine doing anything else. I look forward to providing the best customer experience and helping clients reach their own real estate goals.

Stacy Barry
CENTURY 21 Scheetz
★★★★★2,100+ sales
Stacy Barry Team A recognized name and brand in the Indy real estate market, Stacy Barry is not only distinguished as a top-producing REALTOR®, but a leader in the industry.With an education degree from Indiana University, her time spent teaching prepared her with skills that set her apart from her competition: especially, listening, responsiveness and compassion. It’s because of her ability to listen toher clients’ needs and deliver results that continue to outperform expectations,that her business continues to grow from repeat business and referrals.Stacy is a beloved member of her community, a parent in the local school system, and an advocate for local and small businesses. Her high-involvement and giving back, have equipped Stacy with the contacts and expertise to streamline the transaction process for her clients. With extensive knowledge of the area, and her finger on the pulse of the areas’ housing markets, Stacy is not only an expert at helping you buy and sell your home, but she has also helped local builders sell new construction home sites. Stacy also keeps her pulse on the local market, owning a local Airbnb, several rental properties & flips homes as well.Stacy has earned the 5 Star REALTOR® Award given to less than 7% of REALTORS® in the Indianapolis area. She is also consistently recognized annually in the Indianapolis Monthly Magazine & Indianapolis Business Journal as an All-Star.The relocation designation she has earned to help buyers and sellers’ transition in and out of Indiana for the past 15 years helps allows her to provide a smooth transition for relocation clients.Most recently, the personal experience of grieving the loss of her father, while dealing with his estate, led Stacy to provide a thoughtful and compassionate option to her clients to assist loved ones moving into the next phase of their life or helping families liquidate properties with minimal to no out-of-pocket expense.Also, considered an expert on lake properties, Stacy is an active member of the Sweetwater/Cordry Lakes community located in Brown County Indiana. She enjoys helping clients buy or sell their lake property and is it where she enjoys spending her spare time with family and friends.

Kristie Smith
Indy Homes
★★★★★2,000+ sales
Welcome to a different kind of real estate experience! We do business differently by practicing evidenced-based real estate in everything we do for you. The way we work is by continually tweaking systems, communication & consultation by utilizing proven technologies and best-practices.Due to our unique strategies, my Indy Homes Team is one of the largest real estate teams in Indiana, selling over $60M in real estate annually. Led by myself, Kristie Smith, the team continues to grow year-over-year.Specializing in WOW service, Indy Homes is the only Indiana REALTORS winning the Angie's List Super Service Award all twelve years the real estate category has been in-place.And, we do it all through core values from which we develop our culture, our service, and our business strategies.These are the ten core values that we live by:Play Big and Do Whatever-It-Takes, Deliver a WOW Service Experience, Be Intentional, Passionate and Determined, Be Yourself and Have Fun, Create WIN-WINs, Open and Honest Relationships, Be Adventurous Creative and Open-Minded, Pursue Growth and Forever Learning, Build a Positive Team and Family Spirit, Practice Generosity, Celebrate SuccessesWe welcome your business, and we promise to earn your trust.

Eric Forney
Livian - Catalyst
★★★★★1,800+ sales
Finding the right real estate agent means finding someone who possesses extensive market knowledge, delivers outstanding client satisfaction, and is committed to always negotiating with your best interests in mind. I am able to provide you all of that and more by helping you manage the details of your transaction, and navigate the often overwhelming real estate market. My commitment to delivering an outstanding level of client service, my relentless work ethic, and an extensive background in negotiation skills, allow me to deliver unparalleled results and maximize the financial impact of your home.As a business owner and investor I understand the importance of creative marketing, prompt follow up with a purpose, and maximizing profit margins by differentiating myself and my clients from competitors. Whether you are an experienced investor or a first time buyer, I can help you with the property of your dreams. Please feel free to browse my website or let me guide you every step of the way by calling or e-mailing me to set up an appointment today.

Shannon Gilbert
Highgarden Real Estate
★★★★★1,400+ sales
Shannon Gilbert is dedicated to customized real estate marketing and service excellence. Whether you are buying or selling a home, interested in new construction or foreclosures, you will benefit from a more personalized approach and marketing strategies tailored to meet your specific needs.Ranked in the top 25 agents in the state of Indiana, her knowledge and experience can help you more effectively achieve your real estate goals. Shannon sells homes all over the Indianapolis area with a strong focus in Hamilton County. She started her real estate journey in 2009 and in 2014 she formed The Gilbert Group. Over the years many agents have had the opportunity to train under The Gilbert Group but two agents have truly emerged as leaders. Dawna Ridgeway, fresh into real estate, came on in 2016 with Jamie Ball following in 2017. Working side by side for over 6 years they are now known in the industry as a team that produces results for not only their clients but also their fellow agents. The girls are supported by Addison Altum, who runs the back end of the business, an in-house stager and a full marketing staff. This has allowed them to dedicate more time to market research and strategic online marketing for their listings.Shannon has a passion for technology and a knack for staying ahead of the curve in the real estate market. Her expertise in the industry helped her become the TOP MIBOR agent for lowest days on market in 2020 at 17 days. She is highly ranked in customer services across all of the most popular real estate platforms. Her client reviews reveal her personable nature, strong industry/area knowledge and quick response time.Personal facts about Shannon: Originally for Northwest Indiana, she graduated from Purdue University and moved to the Indianapolis area settling down in Boone County. In 2009 she built a home in Noblesville, settling there until 2012 to move to Fishers. As a single mom of two girls, Grace and Claire, her life is always busy and on the go. She is involved at Fall Creek Intermediate and Junior High where the girls attend school. Her kids are active in organized sports in Fishers and she loves to be a part of the community. You may see her walking around town with her two Vizsla's, Chance and Cooper. She has a passion for life, with family and career being her main focus.

Diane Brooks
FC Tucker Company, Inc.
★★★★★1,200+ sales
With the kind of know-how that comes from 20+ years of successfully selling real estate, Diane can handle the most complicated real estate transactions. Combined with her insight into the Indianapolis and northern suburbs areas, Diane has become our local expert at putting together smooth, trouble-free transactions. Ranked at the top of her company and consistently a best-seller in the Carmel area, Diane's sales in 2018 exceeded $28,970,000! Diane's business has consistently come through referrals, past clients and a growing group of clients who find her through the Internet. (Yelp, Zillow, Facebook and Instagram) Many clients have chosen Diane to buy or sell their home multiple times.

Kim Carpenter
Trueblood Real Estate
★★★★★1,200+ sales
I consider myself an Illini, though I have lived in Indiana for more than half of my life. Born and raised in Southern Illinois, I grew up in very small communities, graduating with a class of 62 students. I think that has contributed to my outgoing personality, I never meet a stranger, because living in such small communities, you knew everyone. I was blessed to marry my wonderful husband of 40 years, after meeting him in college. He is a project manager at Technicolor. We have two great children, a daughter, Karissa, who is a Physician Assistant in Florida and a son, Josh, who graduated from the Kelley School of Business at Indiana University with a marketing degree and currently works as part of my team. They keep me busy but, I pride myself in always living a balanced life.After working in the accounting field for several years, I decided to take advantage of the opportunity to stay home and raise my children. After they were both in school full time, I needed to get back into the business world, so I took a part time job as an unlicensed assistant at Re/Max Ability Plus. I guess you could say real estate is in my blood; my mother is the broker/owner of Knox County Realty in Vincennes, Indiana. I received my real estate license in March of 1997 and continued at Re/Max as a licensed assistant. In August of 1997, I began my career with Century 21, when I accepted a position as a licensed assistant at Century 21 at the Crossing. As my business grew, I felt the need to further my career, when I was invited to become a member of The Richwine Real Estate Group at Century 21 Realty Group I. Continued my journey with the Marchant Team at Keller Williams Indianapolis NE, moved on to be on my own at Century 21 Scheetz, where in 2014 I was the top agent for the whole company, not just my location. I moved back to Keller Williams but knew something was missing. I have now found the missing piece, I have joined Trueblood Real Estate, where the agents truly matter. I can't wait to see where we can go with their marketing and support.I recently received my Florida Real Estate license as well and would be happy to assist with your real estate needs on the Sunshine coast.I bring to my business a willingness to work hard but also the ability to keep my priorities in check. I look forward to creating more friendships and providing real estate service that I can be proud of. I have been a resident of Lawrence Township for 30 years and now live in Noblesville. I enjoy spending time with my family and friends, whether it is slipping away to my "Happy Place" or just relaxing at home! Creating friendships.. one home at a time. Brought together by real estate, held together by friendship!

Carrie Holle
Compass of Indiana, LLC
★★★★★800+ sales
The Carrie Holle Group is a full service residential real estate luxury boutique located in downtown Carmel, Indiana. We are a team of Realtors committed to providing extraordinary service while assisting buyers and sellers in Carmel and the surrounding Indianapolis areas. We pride ourselves on being local market experts specializing in luxury homes, existing residential properties, and new construction. It is our goal to work hard and provide the utmost respect for each person's individual needs. Our team of agents can also assist clients in purchasing real estate in any of their other markets nationally. We look forward to helping you with your real estate needs.About Carrie:Carrie grew up in the Chicago-area. After graduating from Purdue University with a BA in Broadcast Journalism, she moved to Carmel and started her career as a Realtor with a local builder, Crossmann Communities, in 1995. In 2000, Carrie was integral in developing and opening Easystreet Realty/ Highgarden Real Estate which grew and expanded to 16 locations nationwide. In 2015, Carrie opened an independent luxury real estate consulting firm, The Carrie Holle Group, in the Carmel Arts and Design District, and runs one of the highest-producing teams in the metropolitan-Indianapolis area. She specializes in the luxury market for both buyers and sellers. Carrie has an incredible knowledge of the Carmel/Westfield real estate market and regularly serves as a consultant to the largest local developers and builders in the area. In 2018, Carrie was appointed by Mayor Jim Brainard to the Plan Commission for the City of Carmel and is a member of the Residential Committee. She has served as the President of the Park Tudor Parents’ Association, a member of the Bridgewater Club Advisory Board, a founding board member of Carmel Porchfest, and the host of the television show Indy Home and Design. She has been named a Five Star Agent annually since 2012 and was recognized as Indy’s Top Producer in 2018. Carrie resides in Carmel with her husband Brian, three sons, and dogs Walter and Ralphie. * #1 Real Estate Team in Hamilton County*Certified Luxury Home Marketing Specialist (CLHMS)*Over $800 million in sales*Relocation Specialists *Builder Consultants (Custom and Production)*Serving Carmel, Westfield, Noblesville, Fishers, Geist, Zionsville, and Washington TownshipWe Are Carmel Real Estate®

Stephanie Marshall
eXp Realty
Real estate is more than transactions to me—it’s about helping people make decisions that shape their lives. I’m Stephanie Renee, a licensed real estate professional who believes buying or selling a home should feel clear, supported, and intentional, not rushed or overwhelming. I take a thoughtful, strategic approach to real estate—one rooted in honest communication, strong advocacy, and respect for your goals. I understand that real estate decisions often come during pivotal life moments—new beginnings, transitions, growth, or change. That’s why I focus on guidance over pressure and clarity over chaos. My role is to help you understand your options, ask the right questions, and move forward with confidence—whether you’re buying your first home, selling a property, or planning your next step. What sets me apart is how I show up for my clients. I listen closely, communicate clearly, and stay fully engaged from our first conversation through closing. I combine market knowledge with strong people skills, ensuring you feel informed, respected, and supported every step of the way. I don’t believe in one-size-fits-all real estate. I believe in personalized strategy, transparency, and doing things the right way—even when it takes a little more care. If you’re looking for a real estate professional who is grounded, strategic, and genuinely invested in your success, I’d be honored to work with you.
What People Are Saying
“Agent Fixup helped us find the right real estate agent in less than a day. They listened to our wants and needs and made sure the agent we chose would be a good fit for us.”
Frequently asked questions
- Why hire a top real estate agent in Hamilton County, IN?
- Whether you are buying or selling across Hamilton County, IN, working with a proven local agent matters. The top real estate agents in Hamilton County, IN help sellers net more and close faster, and help buyers save on average thousands of dollars per purchase.
- How does Agent Fixup choose agents in Hamilton County, IN?
- We rank the real estate agents serving Hamilton County, IN across multiple metrics — past sales, verified reviews, and overall experience — and recommend who fits your move best. Our approach is unbiased; we surface only top performers.
- What does it cost to use Agent Fixup in Hamilton County, IN?
- Agent Fixup is free for buyers and sellers in Hamilton County, IN. We are paid a referral fee by the agent only after a successful closing, so there is no cost or obligation to you.
Ready to find the right agent in Hamilton County, IN?
Compare top local agents based on real sales data and verified client reviews. Our matching service is free and takes less than 5 minutes.
Compare Agents